The Council of State orders theadministration to reimburse the damages paid pursuant to a criminal judgment

A company was subject to a VAT audit. The French Tax Authority (administration ) subsequently requested that the company return a VAT refund it had received, which the company did on August 31, 2017, after losing its case before the administrative courts.

In parallel with the tax proceedings, the French Tax Authority (administration ) had filed a complaint for fraud against the company’s manager. In 2013, the Court of Appeals upheld his conviction, ordering him, among other things, to pay the government damages in an amount equal to the tax assessment imposed on the company“as compensation for the loss suffered by the Treasury, calculated based on the refund claims filed by him on behalf of [the company].” This amount was paid by the manager on September 6, 2017.

He then filed a lawsuit with the administrative courts to hold the State liable and, in the alternative, to seek reimbursement of the amount he had paid on the grounds of unjust enrichment of the State.

The Conseil d'Etat, to which the dispute was referred, will first dismiss the liability claim.

The court then ruled that the State had received unjust enrichment, noting that the manager“is justified in arguing that the State, by retaining the sum of 257,257 euros that he had paid on September 6, 2017, even though that sum had no other purpose than to compensate the public treasury for the loss caused by the failure to pay the value-added tax owed by the company […]—the collection of which had become final—thereby unjustly enriched itself at his expense.”

Conseil d'Etat rejected the minister’s argument that the manager’s appeal was a separate remedy from the one available to the company to challenge the assessment before the tax court.

administration . is therefore ordered to reimburse the manager for the amount he paid.

CE, Chapters 9 and 10, Nov. 10, 2026, No. 504547, Lebon

This legal watch produced by Mispelon Avocat, a law firm specializing in French tax audit and French tax litigation. You can follow this legal watch subscribing to the newsletter via this link.

Previous
Previous

A notice of " reassessment proposal " served by a bailiff may be invalid

Next
Next

Tax Rulings by the Supreme Courts from November 9 to 13, 2026