A real estate investment company (SCI) that owned a villa and was subject to corporate income tax was the subject of a tax audit. Following the audit, the French Tax Authority (administration ) determined that the lease of the villa to the SCI’s partners had been entered into at an abnormally low price, which constituted an abnormal management act. A tax assessment was then issued not only to the company but also to its partners on the grounds of hidden benefits.
This reassessment was challenged all the way to the Court of Appeals ( Conseil d'Etat).
The method used by the French Tax Administration (administration ) to assess rent—which served as the basis for the tax adjustment—was challenged by taxpayers, among others.
The High Court will then note that if theadministration is unable to find similar properties to use as comparables for determining the rent, it may prove that the rent is unreasonable by any means.
In its decision, the court states for the first time that“in the specific case where the taxpayer asserts—to justify the significant discrepancy thus identified—that it stems from the application of the legal provisions governing rent adjustments, and where the taxpayer establishes that, since the lease was entered into, he has in fact carried out the adjustments or reassessments permitted by those provisions, it is then up to the taxadministration, if it believes it has grounds to do so, to establish that the rent, as of the date the leases were entered into, was already significantly undervalued.”
The taxpayers argued, in particular, that the law of July 6, 1989, had prevented the rent from being adjusted.
The Council thus overturns the ruling of the Administrative Court of Appeals, which had held that this law had no bearing on the characterization of the abnormal management act, and remands the case to the Administrative Court of Appeals for a new trial.
CE, 8th and 3rd Chambers, Nov. 18, 2026, No. 511305, Lebon T.
This legal watch produced by Mispelon Avocat, a law firm specializing in French tax audit and French tax litigation. You can follow this legal watch subscribing to the newsletter via this link.

